Site preloader
Investment, Start Up

Equity vs Valuation

October 3, 2017

I’ve had a few months off from writing due to some significant goings-on at Pi Labs as well as a summer break. But that has given me plenty of time to reflect on various issues in the sector and over the next few months I will be penning some thoughts on these.

 

We’re in the middle of a slew of deals and, not for the first time, we are having some lively discussions with entrepreneurs about what the correct entry “price” is for investors for this particular stage of investment in the company’s cycle. In doing so, this has highlighted what appears to be a common difference between investors and founders. In a nutshell, investors care about the equity they get; founders care about the valuation. Of course, there is a strong relationship between the two given the way venture financing works, but it’s the starting point that’s relevant in terms of ambitions, alignment and rationale.

 

Valuations for companies at an early stage are a vanity metric. As an investor I have almost no interest in what the valuation is on day 1. Instead, I am keenly focused on the following objectives:

 

·         The potential valuation in five year’s time and ensuring the correct foundations are in place to give the management team and the company the best possible chance of hitting that target.

 

·         Ensuring the right amount of equity is on offer to reward myself and my fellow investors in the round for the risk they are taking.

 

·         Lastly, ensuring that the second objective aligns, rather than conflicts, with the first.

 

  1.       Future Valuation Target

 

When we analyse the total addressable market, revenue opportunity and pricing model of a potential company, we are doing so to work out how big the potential is. (We are also looking at the efficiency of the business model to see how optimised it is, but that can always be tweaked). Different investors will want different market sizes before they invest, and that is normally a factor of the size of their fund or the stage at which they invest or both. For Pi Labs, that requirement is £100m. That is, we expect every company, should we invest, to have the ability to reach a £100m valuation within 5 years. For a company with the correct tools, this is not as daunting as it sounds. Depending on the market and multiples in use, that is something between £10m and £20m in revenue and I have seen companies priced at much higher multiples than that.

 

So, we’ve done some preliminary DD and we’ve established that a company is operating in a multi-billion £ market globally. Should it prove successful, it has every chance of hitting the required threshold of £100m. The next issue to tackle is to ensure that the company has the right foundations to reach such a goal. What does that mean? Well, too often companies cut themselves off at the knees because they have taken certain measures which makes this path more difficult, if not impossible:

 

·         You need an outstanding team, both present and future, to have any chance of success. In practical terms, this means two things: (i) ensuring the founders/senior management team have enough equity day 1 to keep them aligned through multiple rounds of financing. Coming back to my first objective above, it does not matter what equity the founders hold today. What matters is what equity they hold at exit and whether that produces a significant enough outcome to ensure alignment. (ii) Where there are gaps in the team, we certainly need an option pool to attract and retain top talent.

 

·         For the company to grow, it is almost certainly going to need multiple rounds of financing. This is 99.99% true. This isn’t about cost controls or burn rates (though that matters); its about growth. To grow meaningfully at an early juncture, you need capital to invest in the company infrastructure – marketing, sales, tech, product and so on. And lets assume that requires 5 rounds of funding. A seed round, plus a further 4 rounds. (Note this is the requirement to the £100m minimum threshold, not necessarily beyond). That is not unusual – a larger seed round, followed by A-C rounds. So when thinking about founder equity, this is why we think about what they have day 1 as they will almost certainly go through multiple rounds of dilution and every investor at every stage will want comfort around the alignment and motivation of the key individuals.

 

·         A second part of this is to ensure the company can attain the milestones to achieve the future fundraises. An extremely common error is not raising enough cash to hit the next milestone, either because you have factored in reaching said milestone unreasonably quickly or you have ignored how much time it takes to raise the next round of financing assuming you have the metrics. Everything being equal, timelines to raise capital are getting longer, not shorter. In my view, it takes 6 months from start to finish to raise a good round – that is from good investors, that is well thought through and results in a deal everyone is very happy with. It could take longer.

 

This 6 month window creates a problem. Classically, you rarely have the metrics required at the start of the 6 month fundraising window, but are approaching them at the end. So you need to factor in enough time to attain the metrics, then add 6 months onto that to raise and close the subsequent round.

 

  1.       Risk vs Reward

 

As a VC, we are financially motivated. We are motivated by soft factors too of course but make no bones about why our investors gives us cash to invest. It is because they believe they will see a strong return on their investment. In order to achieve said return, almost certainly the key factor will be the amount of equity held at exit. Clearly the size of the exit matters too, but this is much more difficult to control at a very early stage. So we need to ensure adequate ownership upfront.

 

But away from returns, we are very often the first institutional capital a company raises. As an investor, we take the highest amount of risk relative to other investors in the VC spectrum and that risk needs to be compensated. The risk is not linked to the size of the cheque or the size of the round.

 

  1.       Managing the Conflict

 

The eagle-eyed amongst you will have spotted that there is a potential conflict between the two points above. We want to protect against founder dilution too early yet we also believe we should be compensated for the risk we are taking with an appropriate amount of equity. To mitigate this, we operate in a 15% – 25% range for total equity on offer in a financing round. We never go below 15% on a priced round and we prefer very strongly to not go above 25% for the round. Where we end up depends on the company’s relative progress in terms of traction, product and revenue. This often requires work on both sides.

 

You will have noticed that I have not mentioned the valuation of the company once. And that is reflective of our own internal discussions too. So my advice to founders is to move the attention away from that metric and focus on (i) raising the optimal amount of cash to grow your business (ii) from a good group of investors who will assist that progression and (iii) for an amount of equity that does not overly dilute you but yet correctly aligns the interests of your investors. This, at the end of the day, is a great deal for both sides and ultimately what both sides should be aiming for.

 

DW

4

Comments

  1. leticia

    September 30, 2020 at 11:00 am Reply

    Hi Everybody
    Thanks for checking out my academic writing page . My name is Leticia Figueroa.
    I have worked a long time in this niche. My interest in writing started at a young age. I wrote poetry as a child and eventually went on to work with my school newspaper.
    This early tryst into reporting eventually led me to academic writing. There is plenty of work for qualified writers. I specialize in essays, but have the skills to do all types of academic writing.
    Email me for more information about rates and a price quote. I’m looking forward to helping you.

    Academic Writer – Leticia – http://www.magnoliacharterschools.org Team

  2. Stephenzep

    October 28, 2020 at 3:21 pm Reply

    viagra online canada viagra viagra pills

  3. GeorgeDucky

    October 30, 2020 at 10:23 am Reply

    viagra from canada buy viagra generic cvs viagra

  4. JeremyKem

    October 31, 2020 at 5:48 pm Reply

    30ml liquid cialis tadalafil cialis side effects

  5. Edwardwhiff

    November 1, 2020 at 6:41 pm Reply

    no prescription viagra order generic viagra buy viagra online cheap

  6. Samuelsor

    November 2, 2020 at 10:49 pm Reply

    buy ed drugs online medications ed pills online pharmacy

  7. RogerFoume

    November 4, 2020 at 2:59 pm Reply

    can you buy viagra over the counter buy ed pills online cost of viagra
    buy drug online

  8. RogerFoume

    November 5, 2020 at 7:49 am Reply

    generic viagra buy viagra online is viagra over the counter
    best ed treatments

  9. RogerFoume

    November 6, 2020 at 12:57 am Reply

    mexican viagra buy generic drugs viagra from canada
    ed in men

  10. PeterHaf

    November 10, 2020 at 7:36 pm Reply

    cialis without a doctor prescription buy cialis online cialis lowest price

  11. PeterHaf

    November 11, 2020 at 11:06 am Reply

    daily use cialis cost buy cialis generic cialis coming out

  12. ThomasLic

    November 13, 2020 at 4:59 pm Reply

    ed pills cheap canadian drug pharmacy best otc ed pills
    ed pills that really work

  13. ThomasLic

    November 14, 2020 at 10:19 am Reply

    buy ed pills online best price for generic viagra on the internet ed solutions
    ed clinic

  14. Obeurf

    November 15, 2020 at 11:24 pm Reply

    essays for sale online – writing essays for money custom essay papers

  15. ThomasCoush

    November 16, 2020 at 2:46 am Reply

    zantac online order zantac

  16. Ixktco

    November 16, 2020 at 9:42 pm Reply

    my best friend essay writing – writing assignments essay writer

  17. ThomasCoush

    November 16, 2020 at 10:37 pm Reply

    how to get ventolin over the counter ventolin prices in canada

  18. ThomasCoush

    November 17, 2020 at 5:59 pm Reply

    where can i buy valtrex online generic valtrex online without prescription

  19. Robertapets

    November 18, 2020 at 7:24 pm Reply

    cash advance instant online payday loans

  20. Robertapets

    November 19, 2020 at 2:04 pm Reply

    buy tadalafil buy tadalafil online

  21. Robertapets

    November 20, 2020 at 8:43 am Reply

    buy generic drugs from india buy generic drugs online from india

  22. Robertapets

    November 21, 2020 at 3:03 am Reply

    buy generic drugs from canada medications compare pharmacy prices for prescriptions

Leave a comment